Holocaust Controversies BST: Introduction | Winston Smith Ministry of Truth Archive

Tuesday, 17 April 2012

HC BST: Introduction

http://holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.co.uk/2011/12/belzec-sobibor-treblinka-holocaust_24.html

"The following year, perhaps inspired by the success of the 9/11 conspiracy video 'Loose Change', another American Revisionist, 'denierbud' (aka ‘Mike Smith’ from California), released the first substantive attempt at a Revisionist You Tube documentary, the 30-part ‘One Third of the Holocaust’ video." (p.6)

Denierbud is on record from 2008 stating "I think 9-11 happened just like the media says it did." And later wrote "9-11 conspiracy theories are just nonsense." So guessing that his inspiration was "Loose Change" is just "nonsense."

http://barnesreview.org/wp/archives/395 - interview - youtube comment

"Reading through the collective works and online comments by MGK, it becomes clear to the reader that the trio possess a high degree of resentment and contempt for those who tell a different history than the one they half-heartedly propose. In many instances Holocaust survivors have been blatantly described as liars and stupid." (p.13)

Holocaust Controversies' Andrew E. Mathis (who is thanked on page 36 for his contribution to HC BST), in his article Hitler the Jewish Zionist, published on Holocaust Controversies' blog on July 26, 2007, calls Polish Jew, Warsaw Ghetto and Bergen Belsen survivor Professor Israel Shahak "a court-affirmed liar." The high degree of resentment and contempt Holocaust Controversies' Andrew E. Mathis displays is blatant, as well as his claim being both stupid and a lie. Mathis' source for his description of the late Israel Shahak as "a court affirmed liar" is an article entitled A Modern Blood Libel written in 1966 by chief rabbi of the British Commonwealth and eugenics proponent ("to limit this particular trend" ie male homosexuality) Immanuel Jakobovits. His article is full of hysterical references to "unbaptized Jews", "falsifying the truth", blood libels, the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion, Julius Streicher and Der Struemer, but nowhere does Jakobovits provides any proof whatsoever for his assertion that Israel Shahak had fabricated an entire incident merely to, as he insinuates, Jew-bait religious Jews. Israel Shahak of course never changed his version of events (of what is known as the "telephone incident" which occurred in 1965), and which he wrote about in the opening lines of his 1994 critically acclaimed book Jewish History, Jewish Religion, The Weight of Three Thousands Years. Mathis' source is the "liar" and Mathis is aptly described in HC BST: he "possess a high degree of resentment and contempt for those who tell a different history than the one" he "half-heartedly" propose(d)."

http://holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.co.uk/2007/07/hitler-jewish-zionist-part-i.html - captured copy - Jakobovits' 1966 article

"... the negationist insists on repeating, over and over, that there is “no document” which might “prove” gas chambers at Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka. Well, duh. The files went up in smoke." (p.32)

Indeed, Treblinka survivor & locksmith Eugen Turowski, who swore under oath that John Demjanjuk was the infamous Treblinka guard "Ivan the Terrible," also claimed that German documents which would have proved gassings at Treblinka, were kept in a safe with a self-destruct mechanism.

http://winstonsmithministryoftruth.blogspot.co.uk/2011/09/treblinkas-safe-with-self-destruct.html

" ... would the world regard Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka as Nazi extermination camps where hundreds of thousands of Jews were murdered if there were no surviving witnesses? The answer is an unequivocal yes." (p.32)

Over-egged the pudding there.

"In particular, the documentation of mass killing by shooting in the territories occupied by Germany after June 1941 is quite extensive, while documents relating to gassing in Poland is scant. For gassing, therefore, witness testimony and circumstantial evidence play a much larger role."

- Evidence for the Implementation of the Final Solution: Electronic Edition, by Browning, Christopher R. III. Implementation of the Final Solution, 3.2

"What is the evidence for mass extermination of Jews at those camps? The consequence of the absence of any overt documentary evidence of gas chambers at these camps, coupled with the lack of archaeological evidence, means that reliance has to be placed on eye witness and circumstantial evidence."

- Justice Gray, Judgment 6:80, Irving vs. Penguin & Lipstadt trial

"No serious scholarly project is ever completed without help from others, and our critique is no exception." (p.36)

"... the cherrypicked hearsay crap that Kues hypocritically parades as evidence." (p.36)

"... we will simply notch up ‘Belzec electric chambers’ alongside many another idiotic meme on the Denier Bullshit Bingo scorecard." (p.52)

"... the report-writers sat around the Shits ‘n’ Giggles department at Hoaxter Central and deliberately decided to leave Important Clues for conspiraloons to seize upon decades later." (p.60)

"Any argument insinuating or claiming coercion or ‘scripting’ is in fact refuted by two favourite gambits on the Denier Bullshit Bingo scorecard, namely the repetition of wartime hearsay reports of ‘electricity’ and ‘steam’ as killing methods in the prosecution case at Nuremberg." (p.70)

"As mentioned, arguments not told in narrative form often fail a simple bullshit test." (p.527)

Tuesday, 17 April 2012

HC BST: Introduction

"When a Jew, in America or in South Africa, talks to his Jewish companions about 'our' government, he means the government of Israel."

- David Ben-Gurion, Israeli Prime Minister